Luchs Children's and Young Adult Prize

2002

School Library Journal

"This unique combination of text and artwork sets this title apart in the expansive world of juvenile historical fiction."

Kirkus Reviews

"A sentimental mid-20th-century novel about child labor is given striking, graphic life by a modern illustrator. … The original story runs to some 500 pages, but illustrator Binder has drastically cut this, relying instead on dramatic black-and-white engravings to move the narrative along. Not so much a classic graphic novel, this offering instead relies on traditional text blocks accompanied by and interspersed with comic book-style panels. Their Gothic darkness complements the melodramatic text, depicting both horror and wonder with equally freighted emotion.… a haunting, praiseworthy effort that deserves recognition."

Booklist

"As much social commentary as drama, it can be read satisfyingly at several levels: as historical fiction, as allegory, and as a rendering of human experience that words alone cannot convey. The rich, evocative artwork stands in sharp contrast to a narrative voice that is understated … it has much to offer readers interested in how a writer uses fiction to increase social awareness and an artist uses image as narrative."

School Library Journal

"This unique combination of text and artwork sets this title apart in the expansive world of juvenile historical fiction."

Kirkus Reviews

"A sentimental mid-20th-century novel about child labor is given striking, graphic life by a modern illustrator. … The original story runs to some 500 pages, but illustrator Binder has drastically cut this, relying instead on dramatic black-and-white engravings to move the narrative along. Not so much a classic graphic novel, this offering instead relies on traditional text blocks accompanied by and interspersed with comic book-style panels. Their Gothic darkness complements the melodramatic text, depicting both horror and wonder with equally freighted emotion.… a haunting, praiseworthy effort that deserves recognition."

Booklist

"As much social commentary as drama, it can be read satisfyingly at several levels: as historical fiction, as allegory, and as a rendering of human experience that words alone cannot convey. The rich, evocative artwork stands in sharp contrast to a narrative voice that is understated … it has much to offer readers interested in how a writer uses fiction to increase social awareness and an artist uses image as narrative."

Voice of Youth Advocate

"A classic tale of survival and the endurance of the human spirit. Neumeyer's excellent translation is underscored by Binder's dark and poignant illustrations. The harsh Italian countryside is etched into life, along with Giorgio's struggles. Young adults might be reluctant to pick up this book, given its historical nature. Nevertheless it is a quick read that grabs and hold the reader to the last page. This graphic novel is one that is sure to uplift and inspire."

Instructor

"This exposé of child labor from 1941 focuses on the working conditions of young Italian chimney sweeps. Readers will applaud the way panels and insets are utilized to heighten emotion."

Language Arts

"This story of courage and fortitude uses a compelling combination of text and pictures to show the reader a historical period when young boys were made to work in dreadful and life-threatening conditions. It also shows readers that good can come from even the darkest of circumstances. Students who enjoy creating or viewing visual art will love seeing how the artwork supports and enhances the storyline."